Review by Amanda Hale
Alma Rosé was an Austrian violinist and conductor, and the niece of Gustav Mahler. In July 1943 she was deported to Auschwitz-Birkenau where she formed and directed the Women’s Orchestra.
But that orchestra was not really about music, or even about music as resistance; it was purely a means of survival. While Alma herself was an acclaimed professional violinist, some of the girls she chose for the orchestra could not even play an instrument. She pushed them hard, rehearsing eight hours a day, under constant threat of death should they lose their protection as “musicians.” Many of these girls were teenagers. Alma gave them a focus, a diversion from the horror that surrounded them as they played while bodies were burned in the nearby crematorium, and skeletal columns of women and girls were marched to labour.
Particularly enlightening is the description of postwar Europe, and the silence of that aftermath. In her meticulous research Sebba follows the surviving members of the orchestra, one of whom, Anita Lasker, now aged 101, writes in her 1996 memoir, “When we first came to England, I badly wanted to talk, but no one asked any questions … people want to protect themselves from too much knowledge … they allow silence to prevail.”
Despite vivid descriptions of daily survival in Auschwitz-Birkenau, this book makes clear the hard fact that such an experience can never be conveyed by words. Sebba acknowledges the irony of hearing from survivors “while remaining aware that for the rest of us, merely trying to frame in words these events risks betraying what was experienced during the Holocaust.”
The world today is rife with unspeakable trauma, yet to be packaged and normalized as historical documentation. And we walk a fine line in order to remember and respect without either succumbing to the silence or attempting to explain and understand. As Sebba writes, “the process normalizes what should remain an outrage beyond explanation.”
Related works: Sarah Helm — Ravensbruck: Life and Death in Hitler’s Concentration Camp for Women. (Also published as If This Is A Woman)
Paradise Road –1997 Australian film about a group of English, American, Dutch, and Australian women who are imprisoned by the Japanese in Sumatra during WW2. They form a vocal orchestra. Featuring Glenn Close, Frances McDormand, Cate Blanchett. The film’s primary credited source is the diary of Betty Jeffrey, an Australian Army nurse. Her experience was published in her 1954 book, White Coolies. The film also draws inspiration from Song of Survival, a1965 book by fellow camp survivor Helen Colijn.



