More Fear and Loathing of Affordable Housing
(Repealing Bill 44: A Victory for NIMBYism) By Keith Porteous
Conservative Premier Doerkson’s proposal to repeal Bill 44 represents a retreat from one of the most worthy housing reforms in British Columbia, one that forced local governments to confront their responsibility for the housing shortage. However, the Denman Local Trust Committee’s attempts at addressing the housing issue started well before the B.C. NDP passed Bill 44.
Fortunately, the architects of Denman Island’s Official Community Plan (OCP) allowed for some flexibility when it created a soft cap on local population, allowing for two non-market based cooperative style densifications, and a 5% increase in the soft cap (about an extra 100 residents). Denman’s current full-time resident population is approx.1600.
The OCP contemplates approx. 2000 residents on Denman if and when every residential property in the Plan is developed, based on the current 2 residents per dwelling average. Bill 44 was an attempt to break the political stranglehold of local NIMBYism by requiring local governments to update their Official Community Plans and zoning bylaws to accommodate greater housing density.
Its purpose was to challenge the entrenched assumption that existing homeowners should have an effective veto over future changes to density bylaws. In Denman’s case, Bill 44 was unnecessary, and its repeal will have little effect. Meanwhile, Hornby Island has recently completed and opened the Beulah Creek Village, a 26 unit non-market rental housing project.
What else should we do? First, we could pressure our Local Trust Committee to “opt in” to the Short-Term Vacation Rental Tax (STR), the so-called “pillow tax”, that creates a fund to support local non-market housing initiatives by taxing local AirBnbs and the like. It’s surprising that the Denman LTC has not already done so, whereas Hornby Island’s LTC has.
Next, the Denman Island LTC could lobby the Province to be included in the Speculation and Vacancy Tax (SVT), which the Province excluded from the Trust Area, and as the Salt Spring Island LTC has already done. Unlike the STR, the SVT doesn’t include a regulatory mechanism allowing LTCs to “opt in.” There are many vacant homes that could become rentals.
The rhetoric of those opposed to affordable housing initiatives on Denman may sound virtuous, but they are largely disingenuous and self-serving. Current homeowners property values benefit from artificial scarcity. We can support the “preserve and protect” Islands Trust mandate and still consider the needs of a younger generation, renters, working families and newcomers effectively excluded from access to secure and affordable housing.
The fundamental problem is that housing scarcity is not simply an unfortunate market accident. It is also the predictable consequence of decades of market housing that has privileged property owners over the needs of supporting a more diverse demographic makeup that can sustain our community.
The central hypocrisy is that a community cannot simultaneously proclaim a housing crisis and then further entrench the very same market structures that have perpetuated it. It would be a capitulation to local political obstructionism dressed up as respect for the values of preserving and protecting, in a cynical and selfish attempt at preserving the privileges of a class of homeowners that threatens the consequence of becoming a gated retirement community.
Younger people and families, and some elders, need access to secure and affordable housing, and for the broader community to support non-market housing initiatives.



