Home Blog Page 18

Phoenix Riting! – April 23rd, 2026

Lately, whenever I ride past that horror of a campground construction zone,” I think of Earth Day. Right now, its two days away. By the time you read this, it will have been yesterday. Close enough — its still Earth Week.

It should be Earth Year. Earth Decade. Earth Millennium. When will we put Earth first? And by Earth, I dont mean the planet as a whole.” I mean the ground under our feet, the creatures we share it with, and our fellow humans. When will we put what is best for life itself first?

Life” includes all life: the animals, the plants, the living biosphere, the Wood Wide Web, the intelligence and interconnectedness of the natural world. When did humanity begin to pry itself apart — to set itself above other life forms, to view itself as exceptional and privileged to dominate, use, control, and destroy, regardless of the harm done to the natural world?

But wait. Was that really humanity”? Tribal cultures have always valued the natural world and viewed themselves as part of the web of life, responsible to, not merely users of, those who share their environment. It is the rich ruling classes, the businessmen, the profit-makers, the warmongers, the conquerors, the corporate overlords who have driven this bus roughshod over the needs and desires of the people” of all species since the beginning of ruling classes.

Im reading a fascinating book called The Dawn of Everything. It challenges the erroneous framing of human history that claims domination and control were the inevitable and necessary result of humans gathering in large cities. Recent discoveries in modern archaeology make clear that this is simply not true.

Ancient humans gathered in large population centres for millennia in social groupings that were egalitarian, defined by three basic freedoms that were once common: the freedom to leave ones surroundings and move away, the freedom to disobey arbitrary authority, and the freedom to reimagine and reconstruct ones society in a different form.

These freedoms kept human society fluid and evolving, and prevented the kind of global domination that has become the norm” today, so thoroughly normalized that few question its necessity. Why try to escape when we believe the prison is the world itself? Where can you go when the walls are made of stone and tower overhead? We are told that such a large population simply must impose top-down controls, arbitrary authority, and punishment for disobedience, and powerful elites must be the ones to make the decisions. Otherwise, wed have anarchy, which means chaos and destruction. Right? 

Yeah, right.

The archaeological record proves there are, and have always been, other ways to live — in harmony with each other, with and within the natural world, in social forms that include freedom and flow. Right now, we are locked into a trajectory leading straight to a hard crash against the limits of growth. There is no Planet B.

Here we are. If we destroy our nest, that will be the end of us. Perhaps a few will escape in rockets to Mars, but the vast bulk of humanity will share the fate of the rest of the natural world. Is this necessary or right?

Hell no, it isnt. There are signs of change, subtle hints that bottom-up growth is solidifying underfoot, as science begins to prove what the tribes have always known: Earth is alive, nature is intelligent, and if we get out of the way, nature will heal itself with astonishing speed.

Technocrats and transhumanists are simply wrong about humanitys right role relative to nature. Earth does not require human intervention to fix the problems human intervention has created. It requires that humans stop intervening so much. Slow down.

The best thing the Covid shutdown did was slow the pace of industrial ravaging of nature, at least for a while. The skies cleared, wildlife began to venture back into the silent cities, and you could feel the Earth relaxing, taking a collective breath. Ahhh.

We are not bad for the Earth. Earth can handle humans. Technocrats, the military-industrial complex, corporate culture, and transhumanism are bad for the Earth. Billionaires are bad for the Earth. Western civilization is bad for the Earth. Something must change, and soon.

Can we turn this thing around? Maybe we dont have to. Maybe the groundswell of awareness of the life we share, its variability, its intelligence and the growth of new technologies that prioritize harmonizing with natures ways, that value ancient forests for more than the board feet they contain, will continue to grow. Maybe, when the top-heavy towers of hierarchical domination fall and the oligarchys disconnection from reality becomes undeniable, we will simply step aside, let them fall, and be there to catch one another, building back something better, different, stronger, and more resilient in how we relate to each other and to Nature.

Maybe. Just maybe. I hope.

Bless this Earth, and the people of all species that share it. May the animal, vegetable, and mineral intelligences bring their teachings into our sphere, so our children can learn to include and cooperate with all beings, to embrace wholeness and real inclusion.

Thats what I think. What do you think? Email me at phoenixonhornby@gmail.com

Letter to the Editor – Bruce Holden

Dear Grapevine,

Alex Allens recent article regarding Earth Day was excellently written and succinct.  It must have taken a lot of energy and research to create it.  What a gem!

Thank you,

Bruce Holden

We Should Not Fear The Tyrants; The Tyrants Should Fear Us

We Should Not Fear The Tyrants; The Tyrants Should Fear Us

Reading by Tim Foley:

If there were a thousand people living on an island, and one of them began making life miserable for everyone else, there would soon be 999 people living on the island.

How strange, then, that a few oligarchs and empire managers get to push around an entire planet full of humans.

I mean, right now we’re all sitting around hoping a few sociopaths in Washington and Tel Aviv don’t collapse the global economy with their reckless warmongering against Iran. There are so many of us and so few of them, and yet everyone’s sitting around going “Golly gosh I sure hope I’ll be able to afford food in the next few months, hopefully the orange guy acts sane and normal for a while so my family gets to eat.”

These are not gods sitting on Mount Olympus exerting omnipotent control over our fate from on high. These are ordinary men with ordinary flesh and bone bodies, walking upon the same earth we walk on. They have soft skin and internal organs. Their heads must remain firmly attached to their necks if they’re to continue to draw breath.

And yet they are permitted to terrorize the people with whom they share a planet.

I am reminded of a quote from Scientific American about an Inuit tribe’s perspective on the problem of psychopathy:

“In a 1976 study anthropologist Jane M. Murphy, then at Harvard University, found that an isolated group of Yupik-speaking Inuits near the Bering Strait had a term (kunlangeta) they used to describe ‘a man who … repeatedly lies and cheats and steals things and … takes sexual advantage of many women — someone who does not pay attention to reprimands and who is always being brought to the elders for punishment.’ When Murphy asked an Inuit what the group would typically do with a kunlangeta, he replied, ‘Somebody would have pushed him off the ice when nobody else was looking.’”

In our society, we do not push psychopaths off the ice when nobody is looking. In our society, we let them rule the world.

We’ve set up systems which elevate those who are willing to do whatever it takes to get to the top, and which protect them once they get there. The ones with the most wealth are the ones who crushed their competitors and exploited the working class the most ruthlessly. The ones who get elected to office are the ones who agree to protect the interests of the rich and powerful no matter how underhanded they have to be. The ones who get promoted to leadership in the military and spy agencies are the ones who’ve demonstrated unwavering loyalty to the bloodthirsty empire they serve.

These systems shield people from the natural consequences of their actions. If you have a lot of money your survival doesn’t depend on getting along with the other members of your tribe; you can just buy whatever services you need, and you can treat the people providing those services like garbage if you pay them enough. If you get elected to office your survival doesn’t depend on advancing the interests of the electorate; you can be as horrible as you like and rely on your security services to protect you.

This is a perversion of the natural order of things. The rich and the powerful should not be allowed to do whatever they want to us and get away with it. They are massively outnumbered. Everything they have, they only have because of us.

Their wealth is dependent on workers and consumers. Their power is dependent on our collectively agreeing to treat made-up rules about government and law like real things. Their lives are dependent on our collectively agreeing not to turn against them in massive numbers and tear them to pieces.

We can have revolutionary change whenever we want to. We already have the numbers. All we need is the will.

_________________

Caitlin’s Newsletter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

The best way to make sure you see everything I write is to get on my free mailing list. My work is entirely reader-supported, so if you enjoyed this piece here are some options where you can toss some money into my tip jar if you want to. Click here for links for my social media, books, merch, and audio/video versions of each article. All my work is free to bootleg and use in any way, shape or form; republish it, translate it, use it on merchandise; whatever you want. All works co-authored with my husband Tim Foley.

Bitcoin donations: 1Ac7PCQXoQoLA9Sh8fhAgiU3PHA2EX5Zm2

Feature image via Adobe Stock.

Winner of the race

#1731

ADIMS Annual Denman Island Beach Cleanup

Organizers from ADIMS estimate they collected between eight and nine tonnes of junk from the beach on Denman Island during the 2019 Big Beach Cleanup - the majority of that coming from the aquaculture industry. Photo by Gerry Ambury Read more at: https://comoxvalleyrecord.com/2020/08/12/column-dfo-should-enforce-regulations-not-pay-for-cleanup/

Denman Community Choir’s Spring Concert

It’s springtime, and the Denman Island Community Choir is back! We’ve been happily gathering since February, preparing to share our voices with you at our annual spring concert on Sunday, April 26 at 2:30 pm at the Community Hall.

Under the direction of Bethany Ireland, the choir will perform songs by Van Morrison, The Beatles, Bruce Cockburn, Harry Belafonte, and Joni Mitchell, along with a few feel-good surprises. The concert will also feature special performances by choir members  Brian Miles and deNeen Baldwin, the FourTune Cookies (a local a cappella octet), and several talented young Denmanites. Gabi Karsten will sing and play guitar, while Tim Hayward and Quinn Ireland will accompany the choir on guitar and bongos for a couple of numbers. With family members joining together on stage, including Tim’s grandfather David and Quinn’s parents Bethany and Steve, the show is sure to be a heartfelt celebration of community and a shared love of music across generations.

We hope you’ll join us for this uplifting afternoon of song. Entry is by donation, with proceeds benefiting WildHaven, a week-long music and dance camp hosted at Camp Denman (formerly Elkhaven) at the end of August. Now in its second year, WildHaven culminates in a memorable performance at the hall, showcasing the talent of Denman youth and the islanders who bring WildHaven to life. The choir is proud to support the continuation of this uniquely Denman experience.

Comox Valley Regional District amends civil claim against Deep Water Recovery

Reprinted with permission from allthingsunionbay.com

Date: April 12, 2026

In a continued effort to halt a company’s shipbreaking operations in the region, the Comox Valley Regional District has amended its civil claim with the Supreme Court of B.C. against Deep Water Recovery Ltd. and Union Bay Industries Ltd.

Deep Water Recovery (DWR) has been breaking down or dismantling end-of-life ships in Union Bay since 2020. But the company’s lack of compliance to environmental regulations has put DWR under a spotlight. 

It’s garnered complaints from concerned citizens and has received over two dozen non-compliance notices from the Ministry of Environment under the Environmental Management Act.

The CVRD’s latest amendment filed on March 25, 2026 builds on its initial claim filed in 2022 stating as the company’s operation at the property are not allowed according to the district’s Industrial Marine (IM) Zoning requirements for land use.

The district filed in court after receiving several complaints on the Deep Water Recovery’s ship recycling operations at 5084 Island Highway in Union Bay.

On Thursday, Alana Mullaly, CVRD’s general manager of planning and development services made the public aware of the amended filing saying “the environmental health of the Baynes Sound is important to the district and our community.”

However, few details were provided as it is an active matter before the court.

“Since the case is ongoing, the CVRD is limited in what information can be shared publicly and cannot comment on the specific details of the proceedings,” the CVRD said in a release.

Province cites lack of compliance and enviromental stewardship, cancels Crown lease

In the summer of 2025, the province cancelled the company’s Crown lease saying its operations were polluting Baynes Sound. It said company lacked the regulatory compliance, operational responsibility, or environmental stewardship required to justify entrusting the use of Crown land to manage and dismantle end-of-life vessels.

Leading up to the cancelled lease, the province says the company failed to comply with the a Pollution Abatement Order (PAO) issued by the Ministry of Environment in 2024 and later amended in May 2025.

This order comes after a series of onsite environmental inspections by ministry staff initiated back in 2022. 

During that time, reports showed a lack of proper drainage and treatment systems resulting in various effluent draining directly to the marine environment. 

In August 2022, staff reported “wood debris; steel scrap; unusable rusted material; septic system discharge; recreational vehicle effluent and surface water effluent. It was also confirmed at this time that there were no treatment systems connected to the Sumps, which are designed to discharge directly to the marine environment when full.”

There were also later tests that showed exceeding levels of copper, lead, zinc and cadmium under the BC Water Quality Guidelines Aquatic Life – Marine. 

After issuing the cancelled lease notice, Deep Water Recovery Ltd. was given 60 days to vacate the site and no longer access its upland operation. That 60 days expired in September 2025.

The cancelled Crown lease relates to the foreshore or water, not the land. Its land operations are under the jurisdiction of the Comox Valley Regional District. 

Deep Water Recovery’s operations have garnered attention from all levels of government as well as environmental groups and concerned citizens.

The district says it “will provide factual updates as permitted.”

With files from Dean Stoltz and Kendal Hanso